English forger of Shakespeare writings, 1775–1835

William Henry IrelandBorn(1775-08-02)2 August 1775Died17 April 1835(1835-04-17) (aged 59)NationalityEnglishOccupationclerk, writer, illustratorKnown forIreland Shakespeare forgeriesNotable workVortigern and RowenaSpousesAlice Crudge (4 July 1796–her death)unknown Ireland, née Bayly, née Pepper (1804–?)ChildrenAnna Maria de Burghanother daughterParents
William Henry Ireland (1775–1835) was an English forger of would-be Shakespearean documents and plays. He is less well known as a poet, writer of gothic novels and histories. Although he was apparently christened William-Henry, he was known as Samuel through much of his life (apparently after a brother who died in childhood), and many sources list his name as Samuel William Henry Ireland.

Early life[edit]
Although Ireland claimed throughout his life that he was born in London in 1777, the Ireland family Bible puts his birth two years earlier, on 2 August 1775. His father, Samuel Ireland, was a successful publisher of travelogues, collector of antiquities and collector of Shakespearian plays and “relics”. There was at the time, and still is, a great scarcity of writing in the hand of Shakespeare. Of his 37 plays, there is not one copy in his own writing, not a scrap of correspondence from Shakespeare to a friend, fellow writer, patron, producer or publisher. Forgery would fill this void.
William Henry also became a collector of books. In many later recollections Ireland described his fascination with the works and the glorious death of the forger Thomas Chatterton, and probably knew the Ossian poems of James Macpherson. He was strongly influenced by the 1780 novel Love and Madness by Herbert Croft, which was often read aloud in the Ireland house, and which contained large sections on Chatterton and Macpherson. When he was apprenticed to a mortgage lawyer, Ireland began to experiment with blank, genuinely old papers and forged signatures on them. Eventually he forged several documents until he was ready to present them to his father.

First forgeries[edit]

In December 1794, William told his father that he had discovered a cache of old documents belonging to an acquaintance who wanted to remain unnamed, and that one of them was a deed with a signature of Shakespeare in it. He gave the document—which he had of course made himself—to his overjoyed father, who had been looking for just that kind of signature for years.
Ireland first forged a letter, that he claimed was written by Shakespeare expressing gratitude towards the Earl of Southampton for his patronage.
Ireland went on to make more findings—a promissory note, a written declaration of Protestant faith, letters to Anne Hathaway (with a lock of hair attached), and to Queen Elizabeth—all supposedly in Shakespeare’s hand. He claimed that all came from the chest of the anonymous friend. He “found” books with Shakespeare’s notes in the margins and “original” manuscripts for Hamlet and King Lear. The experts of the day authenticated them all.
On 24 December 1795, Samuel Ireland published his own book about the papers, a lavishly illustrated and expensively produced set of facsimiles and transcriptions of the papers called Miscellaneous Papers and Legal Instruments under the Hand and Seal of William Shakespeare (the book bears the publication date 1796). More people took interest in the matter and the plot began to unravel.

“This Solemn Mockery”[edit]

In 1795, Ireland became bolder and produced a whole new play—Vortigern and Rowena. After extensive negotiations, Irish playwright Richard Brinsley Sheridan acquired rights for the first production of the play at London’s Drury Lane Theatre for £300, and a promise of half of all profits to the Irelands.
Sheridan read the play and noticed it was relatively simplistic compared to Shakespeare’s other works. John Philip Kemble, actor and manager of Drury Lane Theatre, later claimed he had serious doubts about its authenticity; he also suggested that the play appear on April Fool’s Day, though Samuel Ireland objected, and the play was moved to the next day.
Although the Shakespeare papers had prominent believers (including James Boswell), sceptics had questioned their authenticity from the beginning, and as the premiere of Vortigern approached, the press was filled with arguments over whether the papers were genuine or forgeries. On 31 March 1796, Shakespearean scholar Edmond Malone published his own exhaustive study, An Inquiry into the Authenticity of Certain Miscellaneous Papers and Legal Instruments, about the supposed papers. His attack on the papers, stretching to more than 400 densely printed pages, showed convincingly that the papers could be nothing other than modern forgeries. Although believers tried to hold their ground, scholars were convinced by Malone’s arguments.
Vortigern and Rowena opened on 2 April 1796, just two days after Malone’s book appeared. Contemporary accounts differ in details, but most agree the first three acts went smoothly, and the audience listened respectfully. Late in the play, though, Kemble used the chance to hint at his opinion by repeating Vortigern’s line “and when this solemn mockery is o’er.” Malone’s supporters had filled the theatre, and the play was greeted with the audience’s catcalls. The play had only one performance, and was not revived until 2008.

Forgeries exposed[edit]
A forgery of Shakespeare’s signature by Ireland, circa 1795
When critics closed in and accused Samuel Ireland of forgery, his son published a confession—An Authentic Account of the Shaksperian Manuscripts—but many critics could not believe a young man could have forged them all by himself. One paper published a caricature in which William Henry is awed by the findings when the rest of the family forges more of them (as opposed to what was really going on). Samuel Ireland’s reputation did not recover before his death in 1800.
In 1805 William Henry published The Confessions of William Henry Ireland, but confession did not help his reputation. He took on a number of miscellaneous jobs as a hack writer, but always found himself short of money. In 1814 he moved to France and worked in the French national library, continuing to publish books in London all the while. When he returned in 1823, he resumed his life of penury. In 1832 he published his own edition of Vortigern and Rowena (his father had originally published it in 1799) as his own play with very little success.
There has been recent scholarly interest in his later Gothic novels and his poetry. His illustrated Histories were popular, so to say that Ireland died in obscurity is probably not correct. He was, however, perpetually impoverished; he spent time in debtors’ prison, and was constantly forced to borrow money from friends and strangers. When he died, his widow and daughters applied to the Literary Fund for relief. They received only token amounts.
Ireland is one of the main characters in Peter Ackroyd’s 2004 novel The Lambs of London, though the contacts with Charles and Mary Lamb have no basis in the historical record, and Ackroyd took many liberties with the story.

Bibliography[edit]
An Authentic Account of the Shaksperian Manuscripts (1796)
The Abbess: A Romance (4 volumes), 1799. (Gothic novel. reprinted in 1975, Ayer. ISBN 0-405-18670-3)
Rimualdo: Or, The Castle of Badajos, 1800. (Gothic novel. Reprinted in 2005, (Jeffrey Kahan, editor), Zittaw Press ISBN 0-9767212-1-X)[5]
Gondez the Monk: A Romance of the Thirteenth Century[1] 1805. (Gothic, reprinted in 2005, (Jeffrey Kahan, editor), Zittaw Press ISBN 0-9753395-8-3)
The Confessions of William Henry Ireland (1805)
Scribbleomania: or the Printer’s Devil’s Polichronicon: a Sublime Poem, 1815. (Page images at Google Books)
Henry Fielding’s Proverbs 1822
Memoirs of Jeanne d’Arc, surnamed La Pucelle d’Orleans, 1824 (two volumes). (Page images at Google Books: Volume 1 and Volume 2) a translation of Voltaire’s Pucelle
A New and Complete History of the County of Kent (4 volumes), 1829–31. (Page images at Google Books: Volume 2, Volume 3, Volume 4; reprinted 1919, London: Virtue)
Vortigern: an Historical Play, with an Original Preface, 1832, London: Joseph Thomas.
Ireland’s History of the Isle of Grain, 18xx. (Reprinted in 2002, Local History Publications. ISBN 1-85699-213-6)
A New and Complete History of the Isle of Thanet ISBN 1-905477-10-4
Ireland’s History of Woolwich ISBN 1-85699-202-0
Ireland’s History of Chislehurst ISBN 1-85699-197-0
Ireland’s History of Gravesend ISBN 1-85699-211-X
References[edit]

Sources[edit]

Further reading[edit]

Grebanier, Bernard (1965). The Great Shakespeare Forgery. New York: W. W. Norton and Company. OCLC 313141.
Kahan, Jeffrey (1998). Reforging Shakespeare: The Story of a Theatrical Scandal (illustrated ed.). Lehigh University Press. ISBN 978-0934223553.
Kahan, Jeffrey, ed. (2004). The Poetry Of W.H. Ireland (1801–1815) Including The Poet’s Imitations, Satires, Romantic Verses, And Commentaries On Coleridge, Wordsworth, Southey, And Others. Mellen Press. ISBN 978-0-7734-6269-4.
Lawrence-Young, D. (2014). The Man Who Would Be Shakespeare: The Enigmatic Tale of William-Henry Ireland. Enigma Press. ISBN 978-0692322802.
Lynch, Jack (2004). “William Henry Ireland’s Authentic Forgeries”. Princeton University Library Chronicle. Princeton University Library. LXVI (I): 79–96. doi:10.25290/prinunivlibrchro.66.1.0079.
Lynch, Jack (2007). “The Picaresque Biography: William Henry Ireland”. In Ehland, Christoph; Fajen, Robert (eds.). Das Paradigma des Pikaresken [The Paradigm of the Picaresque]. Heidelberg: Universitätsverlag. pp. 147–57. ISBN 978-3825353483.
Lynch, Jack (2009). “Forging Shakespeare”. Becoming Shakespeare: The Unlikely Afterlife That Turned a Provincial Playwright into the Bard. Walker Books. pp. 204–38. ISBN 9780802718679.
Pierce, Patricia (2004). The Great Shakespeare Fraud: The Strange, True Story of William-Henry Ireland. Sutton. ISBN 978-0750933933.
Schoenbaum, Samuel (1985). “The Ireland Forgeries: An Unpublished Contemporary Account”. In Schoenbaum, Samuel (ed.). Shakespeare and Others. Washington: Folger Books. pp. 144–53. ISBN 978-0918016676.
Schoenbaum, Samuel (1991). Shakespeare’s Lives. Oxford: Clarendon Press. ISBN 0198186185.
Stewart, Doug (2010). The Boy Who Would Be Shakespeare: A Tale of Forgery and Folly. Da Capo Press. ISBN 978-0306819001.
Wilkie, Vanessa (22 April 2020). “A Real Fake: The Shakespeare Forgeries of William Henry Ireland”. Verso – The Blog of the Huntington Library, Art Museum, and Botanical Gardens. Retrieved 26 October 2020.
External links[edit]

Previous

William Shakespeare

Next

Samuel Ireland

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Check Also

Literary forgery

X